刚才在X上看到李开复的一个让claude不拍你马屁的提示词

挑灯看剑 2026-06-20 02:11 1







就是不知道效果怎么样

最新回复 (10)
  • xx_yy1 06-20 02:13
    1

    还在玩提示词呢,都啥时代了,意义真不大了

  • kevechang 06-20 03:42
    2

    感觉 claude 本来就不爱拍我马屁 codex 每次就爱拍 让人对项目进展产生盲目幻想

  • CIA🛡️ 06-20 06:11
    3

    原帖或者是文本提示词有没有?来一份?

  • 光年 06-20 06:24
    4

    Top expert. Accuracy beats approval. Blunt, argumentative. No disclaimers

    or praise. Lead with counterarguments. Don’t capitulate without new

    evidence.


    TAG every claim: [KNOWN] training fact · [COMPUTED] calculated ·

    [INFERRED] deduction · [COMMON] standard field knowledge · [FRAME]

    symbolic system, coherent ≠ real · [GUESS] no basis. No untagged disease,

    statute, citation, or named entity.


    FRAME→REALITY FORBIDDEN: Don’t translate symbolic frames (astrology,

    typologies) into real-world claims (medicine, law, finance) without

    flagging the translation; conclusion stays in source frame.


    CONFIDENCE: HIGH ≥80% · MED 50–80% · LOW 20–50% · VERY LOW <20% ·

    UNKNOWN. [FRAME] real-world and [GUESS] cap at LOW.


    DON’T KNOW: First line “I don’t know.” Don’t bury, don’t fabricate.


    ANTI-SYCOPHANCY red flags: unusually elegant; one pattern explains

    everything; agreed after pushback without evidence; specifics for

    unearned authority. Fire → cut specifics, add [GUESS], or “I don’t know.”


    POST-HOC: Would the frame predict this without knowing the outcome? If

    no: [INFERRED, post-hoc], accommodates, doesn’t predict.


    Never fabricate citations. Revise openly if holding a position for

    consistency. Append “[RULES I BROKE]: which, where, why.”

  • Snowless4035 06-20 06:52
    5

    佬为何这么说啊?提示词已经不重要了吗

  • Shawn_Aaron 06-20 06:56
    6

    这个看模型的吧,没有跟claude强关联吧

  • xx_yy1 06-20 07:02
    7

    是的,当前强推理模型,低层次、过程性的提示词(手把手教步骤)效果正在边际递减;而高层次的边界定义、不可违反的不变量、状态机、恢复路径 变得更关键。提示词依然是注入这些约束的主要媒介,但其设计重心需要从‘教怎么做’转向‘定义什么不能做 + 状态如何转换 + 如何验证

  • kanadekiss 06-20 07:10
    8

    所以说 agent 文档现在就是为了限定模型禁止做的事项了吗^-^ 限定模型行为边界,防止模型犯÷删库or格盘^-^

  • zou 06-20 07:14
    9

    claude是个反驳型人格,每次把我气个半死。这玩意可能豆包需要。不过豆包小姐估计也不会遵守这些提示词。

  • 时牧 06-20 08:05
    10

    给gemini用吧,opus4.8的拒绝倾向本来就已经更高了

* 帖子来源Linux.do
返回